

To change your homeowners insurance, compare new quotes, buy the new policy first, set it to start on the day you want, then cancel the old policy in writing effective that same date. If a mortgage lender pays your premium through escrow, send them the new declarations page so there is no gap in coverage.
Switching home insurance is usually simpler than people expect, but the order of the steps matters. Most problems come from cancelling too early, forgetting the mortgage servicer or comparing policies that are not really alike. This guide walks through how to change your homeowners insurance safely, whether you switch at renewal or partway through the policy term.
There is no single right time, but a few situations are common reasons to review your options:
Changing for price alone can be reasonable, but only if the new policy protects your home at least as well. A lower premium paired with a lower dwelling limit or a much higher deductible is not a like-for-like saving.
In most cases, yes. Homeowners policies are generally not long-term contracts that lock you in, so you can usually change your homeowners insurance at renewal or in the middle of the term. What differs is how the old insurer handles the unused part of the premium you already paid.
Two refund methods are common in the industry:
Which method applies depends on your policy wording, the insurer and state rules. Read the cancellation section of your current policy or ask your insurer before you set a cancellation date. If a short-rate charge applies, waiting until renewal may cost less than switching mid-term.
The sequence below is designed to avoid the biggest risk, which is a period when your home is not insured.
If you are still deciding what level of protection to buy, our guide on how to pick homeowners insurance that fits your rebuild cost explains each choice in more detail.
Many homeowners with a mortgage pay their premium through an escrow account. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) describes escrow as an account a mortgage servicer uses to pay property-related bills, such as property taxes and homeowners insurance, on your behalf. That means your servicer needs to know about any change.
When you switch with escrow, a few extra details matter:
If something goes wrong, the CFPB advises contacting your servicer promptly and, if needed, sending a written request for information or a notice of error.
A gap in coverage is the most expensive mistake you can make when switching. If a fire, storm or liability claim happens on a day when no policy is active, there may be nothing to claim against.
A gap can also cause problems with your lender. Most mortgages require continuous homeowners coverage. If the servicer believes your coverage has lapsed, it may buy force-placed insurance, also called lender-placed insurance, and charge you for it. Under the CFPB’s Regulation X, servicers must send written notices before charging for force-placed coverage, but this type of policy mainly protects the lender’s interest and is often more expensive than a policy you choose yourself.
Some insurers also ask whether you have had a lapse in coverage when they quote, and a lapse may affect future pricing. The simplest protection is to let the new policy start before or exactly when the old one ends.
Both options can work. The table below summarises the main trade-offs.
| Factor | Switch at renewal | Switch mid-term |
|---|---|---|
| Cancellation charge | Usually none, because the old policy simply ends | Possible if the insurer uses a short-rate method |
| Refund handling | Little or nothing to refund | Unused premium refunded, often after a few weeks |
| Escrow changes | Servicer updates billing for the new term | Servicer may have already paid the old premium for the year |
| Best for | Price or service shopping with time to plan | Urgent changes, such as poor claim service or a major home change |
A practical approach is to start comparing about 30 to 45 days before your renewal date. That gives you time to collect quotes, ask questions and arrange the start date without rushing.
Two policies with similar prices can respond very differently when you file a claim. Before you commit, compare these points side by side:
For a plain-English refresher on each part of a standard policy, see what a standard homeowners insurance policy covers.
Most switching problems are avoidable. Watch out for these:
If you want help comparing options, you can learn more about home insurance options from FE Life Insurance.
Often there is not, but it depends on your insurer and policy. Some insurers refund unused premium on a pro-rata basis, while others use a short-rate method that keeps a cancellation charge. Read the cancellation section of your policy or ask your insurer before choosing a date. Switching at renewal usually avoids any charge.
Getting quotes and buying a new policy can take anywhere from a day to a couple of weeks, depending on whether the insurer needs an inspection or more details. Cancelling the old policy is usually quick once you give a written date. Refunds and escrow updates may take a few weeks to settle.
Yes, if you have a mortgage. Your lender or servicer needs proof of continuous coverage and must be listed on the new policy. Send the new declarations page, the mortgagee clause details and billing information. If you pay through escrow, ask how the servicer will handle the next premium payment.
You usually can, but ask both insurers first. Generally, the policy in force on the date of loss handles that claim, even if you later switch. A new insurer may ask about the open claim and any unrepaired damage, so be accurate on your application and keep records of repairs.
If you paid in advance and cancel before the term ends, you will usually receive a refund for the unused portion, minus any cancellation charge your policy allows. With escrow, the refund is often sent to you rather than the servicer. Check the amount against your cancellation date and keep the confirmation.
Learning how to change your homeowners insurance comes down to doing things in the right order. Compare like-for-like quotes based on a realistic rebuild cost, buy the new policy first, cancel the old one in writing on the same date and tell your mortgage servicer. Check how refunds work before switching mid-term, and keep written records of every step so there is never a gap in protection.
This article is for general information only and is not insurance, legal or tax advice. Coverage, eligibility and prices vary by state, carrier and individual circumstances.
Thinking about changing your home insurance? Contact FE Life Insurance to speak with a licensed agent and request a free, no-obligation quote that matches the coverage you need.